Skip to content
Black Holes, drawn

generatorThrow something at it

Pick an angular momentum and an energy. The particle starts at its outer turning point and falls. Newton would draw one ellipse, forever. Einstein draws a rosette, or a whirl, or a plunge.

Units G = c = M = 1; L and E per unit mass of the particle. The right-hand panel is the effective potential V(r) for the chosen L, with E as the dashed line: where the line is above the curve the particle may be. A dip holds it; a rim it clears lets it fall.

Why the rosette

In Newton's gravity the force falls as 1/r², and a 1/r² force is the one case that closes its orbits. Einstein's extra term, 3Mu², is a 1/r⁴ correction. It is tiny far out and everything close in. Mercury's orbit turns 43 arcseconds a century from it; the star S2, passing Sagittarius A* at 120 au, turns 12 arcminutes an orbit, measured by the GRAVITY instrument in 2020[46].

Why the whirl

Just outside the rim of the potential a particle can hover at the edge of an unstable circular orbit, going round and round, before the smallest excess sends it back out. Orbits like that are what gravitational-wave detectors listen for from small things circling big ones; LISA will hear thousands of turns of them.

Why the plunge

Below L = √12 M there is no dip left in the potential. There is no speed, no direction, that keeps the particle out. That is a statement Newton cannot make: his potential has a well for every L above zero.

The effective potential for four angular momenta. The last stable orbit is where the well and the rim meet.
The effective potential for four angular momenta. The last stable orbit is where the well and the rim meet. · SVG · computed here · Nan · hongdam.net · CC BY 4.0